data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0676e/0676e060823f80bb92c8a5b93658486065581d42" alt=""
Number 5 (tie): American Life.
American Life saw Madonna collaborate again with Music producer Mirwais Ahmadzaï, with whom she co-wrote and produced most of the songs on the album.
As much as I personally love this album, I fully understand why so many did not. This is Madonna at her most self centred, singing about her fame, her life, her loves and her self, and being very indulgent while doing so. But after six US number 1 albums, thirty six US top ten singles and sixty UK top 10 singles, why shouldn’t she be indulgent. It seems her taste of English life and the advent of the 'Pop Idol' generation have left her at odds with the world around her.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d809d/d809da866c5671a8e38e9b7578f3701b40a144d6" alt=""
But as an album it works. The lead single, with it’s chunky dirty bass beat verse and acoustic chorus sees her looking at her life and fame in terms of the big picture, and she is not satisfied. When she raps about all she does and has many thought she was bragging and were turned off (although bragging about what you have seems very successful in rap music…hmmm) but failed to see the point that materialism has replaced freedom as the American dream.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6d15a/6d15a26caab2702c93659e6f5cfa4b82bc144225" alt=""
The third track ‘I’m so Stupid’ is a little out of place, and sounds more like a B-side than anything. A guitar driven song still reflecting on fame “Please don't try to tempt me
It was just greed, And it won't protect me” go the lyrics which are at time insightful but mainly clunky “I'm so stupid, 'Cause I used to live, In a tiny bubble, And I wanted to be Like all the pretty people.”
Spectacularly understated 'Love Profusion' gets under your skin and from there grows and captures your heart. She sounds overwhelmingly ecstatic and honest on this song about not just loving your lover, but yourself and everyone around you.
Madonna’s favourite off the album, and an experimental dance number ‘Nobody Knows Me” for all it production and technicality seems to be the complete opposite of why she did ‘Ray of Light’. On that album she said she wanted to give soul to techno music. ‘Nobody Knows Me’ is soul free and all about the techno.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/50c27/50c27eb7e73bb707b70173dd743b6dab48bf6414" alt=""
This is turning out to be the most un-Madonna Madonna album ever as I go into ‘Intervention’ which is a welcome change. A quiet, almost folk song that unless you really listen, you will miss the effect it has. This can also be said for the next track ‘X-Static Process’. On paper this looked like a dance track to rival ‘Impressive Instant’ off the ‘Music’ album. Instead we are met with a intimate duet with herself. “Jesus Christ will you look at me, Don’t know who I’m supposed to be” go the extremely personal lyrics of a truly gracious and beautiful song, tenderly embellished with the lightest of computer-generated touches.
‘Mother and Father’, ‘Die Another Day’ and ‘Easy Ride’ finish off the album. The James Bond song sticks out like a sore thumb on the album, and although musically it fits, it stands out for what it is, the James Bond song. ‘Mother and Father’ on the other hand is the complete opposite of ‘X-Static Process’. On paper this looked to be the albums big personal ballad, in reality it is one of the albums true dance numbers. Like she did before in "Promise To Try", "Inside Of Me" and "Mer Girl", Madonna sings about her mothers death, and how her father dealt with it. But though the lyrics are sad and emotional, the song has an up-tempo dance beat. Madonna's voice is high pitched as if it were a little girl singing about her parents.
Madonna has said of the song “It's a way to free me from the pain for my mother's death, but I'm not asking for a medal for finding my way in life or for compassing for suffering so much. It isn't an excuse like 'I'm like this because I've suffered so much when I was a child.' These excuses are rubbish, because you have to be responsible for all the things you do in your whole life."
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/280cc/280cc9fbd8953d8644ef05bac04d125c741992ee" alt=""
As an Album ‘American Life’ succeeds. She tries something new and it flows (aside from the James Bond song) not beautifully, like a stream, but with twists and turns like I am sure her life at the time was. It may be self indulgent, but why criticize her for something we are all guilty of.
This is the sound of a woman who is seeing her life from a distance, and realizing that there is so much more that what she has. It is her diary of an album. When you put your honest thoughts and feelings about yourself and life out there, that is when you will be criticized the most and have to be defensive. It may be foolish to some to subject yourself to that, but I would rather think of it as brave.
2 comments:
I likes your review and your point of view of this album, I also think it's very underrated, specially with Hollywood, Nothing Fails and X-Static Process, and I think the original American Life video is one of her bests.
I couldn't agree with you more!!!
Post a Comment